Here 'tis – but even knowing the possible methodology makes it still slow going!
Know that start letters from the keywords(brute-forced), which change with every comma.
Write down the individual keyword letter at the beginning of each number group – like a bingo call.
Each number is actually a letter exactly "x" units away,added or subtracted, on an alphabet range (included below for covienience).
Keyword letters + number letters are both needed, in order, for plaintext.
Also each keyword changes with every row. Therefore you need the correctly spaced lines (not smushed together to save space) from the Project Gutenburg Internet Archive Pamplet, or you are sunk.
I am posting because while I seem to have have a definate method that works for both Ciphers 1 and 3, I do not have all the keywords. Also, this is a Level X challenge, so it was posted by admins in the forum that the rules of confidentiality about solutions run differently. If anyone wants to help me finish this nicely for the puzzle archives, I would be grateful, since admins stated that the credit will be shared.
ALPHABET REFERENCE LINE:
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z-A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z
(Beale 1 plays much like Kit Williams "Masquerade" – anyone with surveying equipment and a telescope handy?)
BEALE CIPHER 1 ROW 1 KEYWORD PHRASE "MAY ONE":
Row 1 Raw Numbers:
71, 194, 385, 1701, 89, 76, 11, 83, 1629, 48, 94, 63, 132, 16, 111, 95, 84, 341,
Matched with phrase:
M-71, A-194, Y-385, O-1701, N-89, E-76, M-11, A-83, Y-1629, O-48, N-94, E-63, M-132, A-16, Y-111, O-95, N-84, E-341,
Mtn, Az ke,Y be t, On io m,N vu,E x k,M ln, Aid, Y x ea q, O k w,Nw r, Ez b, Ml pk, Az u Y zx z, O ft, N v r,E b id
(Beale 3 seems to work so that each group of relatives has one line to themselves, with the family member from Beale's Group being their Keyword – but of course, this could change as I delve farther into it.)
BEALE CIPHER 3 ROW 1 Keyword "BEALE":
B317, E8, A92, L73, E112, B89, E67, A318, L28, E96, B107, E41, A631, L78, E146, B397, E118, A98,
Beau, Elary, Leo, Edd C, Bk, Selma, Cas, Lit, Evy, Babie Ada Uxb, L St., Edil, Beki, Eddy, Ari
BEALE CIPHER 3 ROW 2 Keyword "JAKOB":
J114, A246, K348, O116, B74, J88, A12, K65, O32, B14, J81, A19, K76, O121, B216, J85, A33, K66, O15,
J, kim, Acef, K hose, Oppi, Bif Jr, rAby, KepOlm Jr, kAb, j KreOn, m nB dav J, reAdd, Kee, Ont
BEALE CIPHER 3 ROW 3 Keyword "BILLY":
B108, I68, L77, L43, Y24, B122, I96, L117, L36, Y211, B301, I15, L44, L11, Y46, B89, I18, L136, L68,
Babj, Io, aLee, Lio, Yau B, add, IroL, mke, Li f, Yazz, Beb cImeL, mkL, Yue, ButI, hal, mor, Lrt